Skip navigation

Supreme Court challenge highlights broken process for major infrastructure projects

profile image
Sam Hibbins MP
Member for Prahran
12 February 2020

The Victorian Greens have welcomed the newly launched Supreme Court challenge to the North East Link, saying it highlights Victoria’s broken environmental effects process for major infrastructure projects.

Despite both a 2011 parliamentary inquiry and a 2017 Auditor General’s report recommending a strengthening of the Environment Effects Statement (EES) process, Victoria’s Environmental Effects Act remains weak and unable to effectively protect Victoria’s environment.

Problems with the Environmental Effects Act include:

  • A lack of detail in the Act
  • A lack of certainty about when an EES in required and the level of detail involved in its preparation
  • It does not necessarily contribute to good environmental outcomes
  • The non-binding nature of the Minister’s recommendations

Victorian Greens spokesperson for transport, Sam Hibbins, has called on the Government to overhaul the EES process to strengthen protections for Victoria’s environment and give local communities more certainty.

Quotes attributable to Victorian Greens spokesperson for transport, Sam Hibbins MP:

‘The current Environmental Effects Statement laws in Victoria are an effective rubber stamp that permit wholesale environmental destruction.’

‘The Victorian Government has deliberately kept these laws weak to ram through the approval of a mega toll road that will destroy precious threatened species habitat and put a hundred thousand more cars on the road.’

‘The planning Minister’s decision to approve the North East Link based on reference design and to ignore key recommendations from the independent panel shows that the process has no teeth and is unable to effectively protect Victoria’s environment.’

‘Unless there is a complete overhaul of environmental laws covering major infrastructure projects, Victoria’s natural environment will die a death of a thousand cuts.’

profile image
Sam Hibbins MP
Member for Prahran
12 February 2020
SHARE:

WHAT I'M FIGHTING FOR


LATEST NEWS

MEDIA RELEASE

Victoria continues to fall short when it comes to public school funding

MEDIA RELEASE A comparison of state and federal funding agreements has exposed the Andrews Labor Government’s woeful rate of public school funding.   Victoria currently spends less on public schools than any other state or territory in Australia, and with its current agreement, will be the last state to reach...

MEDIA RELEASE

Victorians need certainty that Somyurek didn't meddle with proposed council ward changes

Victorians need certainty that Somyurek didn't meddle with proposed council ward changes 22/06/2020   The Victorian Greens have called on the new minister for local government, Shaun Leane, to ensure that any proposed council ward changes made by Adem Somyurek were done in good faith and not to corrupt local...

PARLIAMENT

Constituency Question: Live Music Venues

Mr HIBBINS (Prahran): My constituency question is to the Minister for Creative Industries, and I ask: will the minister establish a support fund for live music venues so live music venues in the Prahran electorate can survive this pandemic? Live music venues—the clubs and pubs in the Prahran electorate around the...

PARLIAMENT

Members Statement: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander incarceration

Mr HIBBINS (Prahran): Black lives matter, Indigenous lives matter, and I acknowledge in speaking on this issue there is actually no Indigenous person in this place to do the same. The murder of George Floyd, an African-American man, by a police officer in Minneapolis, USA, has turned the world’s attention...